Saturday, February 28, 2009

Income Inequality and Poverty

Income inequality and its distribution are now common phenomena. Many economists now work on it. The income inequality is sharp in lower income countries than middle or higher income countries. Again the income range of low-income countries also very few than other countries.


However, income inequality and poverty are closely related with each other. Inequality creates poverty. Here is proved this statement in two perspectives.

  • Inequality and Inequity
  • Empirical evidence
    Inequality and Inequity: Philip B. Coulter defines "inequality" as a special case of "inequity". If I understand Coulter correctly, then
    • Inequity is the deviation of an observed distribution from any defined reference distribution.
    • Inequality is an inequity for which the reference distribution is defined by Ai/Ei=Ai+1/Ei+1, that is, all shares are evenly distributed.
      In case that inequality is a relative measure, then inequality = 1-equality. As for equal distribution within a group, all members receive the same share. Equities, however, are shared based on the (perceived) value of the receiving individuals. The values of the group members may be determined by merit.

      However, if the income share is not equal in any country then it occurs the following situations.

      Relation of income inequality and poverty:

      • Income inequality.
      • Inequity in the society.
      • Create poverty.
      Inequality and Inequity: Empirical Evidence: For empirical evidence here is considering some matters. These are –
      • GNP per capita, rate of poverty (%) and share of income groups of a country and here the considering country is Bangladesh;  
      • The situations are taken for two decades for finding average trends.

      Table: Relation of income inequality and poverty


      Year

      Share of income groups (%)
      GNP ($)
      Rate of poverty (%)
      1970-80
      45% share of top 20%.
      25% share of middle 40%.
      30% share of bottom 40%


      150
      60
      1980-90
      40% share of top 20%.
      25% share of middle 40%.
      35% share of bottom 40%

      350
      35.6

      Source: Report on Rural Development in CIRDAP member countries, pp 36-63.

      So, from the table it is cleared that for a negligible change of income share a gulf of difference is occurred in poverty situation and GNP per capita.

      Rural Poverty in Bangladesh

      Bangladesh is a developing country in the world. It has many problems like other developing countries. Poverty is a major constraint in the way of economic development of Bangladesh. Now a day the poverty situation of Bangladesh is prospering due to initiatives taken by the government and non-government organizations. From several studies it has been observed that the poverty situation is diminishing slowly day by day. It is a positive factor for the development of the economy. According the household expenditure survey, 1995/96, 47.1% people are staying under the poverty line i.e. they are taking less than 2122 kilocalorie food in a day and 24.6% people are staying under the absolute poverty line i.e. they are taking less than 1805 kilocalorie food in a day. The poverty situation and trend can be present by the following table.

      Table 02. poverty status in Bangladesh(%)

      Region
      1995/96
      1991/92
      1988/89
      1985/86
      1983/84

      Poverty
      National
      47.5
      47.5
      47.8
      55.7
      62.6
      Rural
      47.1
      47.6
      47.8
      54.7
      61.9
      Urban
      49.7
      46.7
      47.6
      62.6
      67.7

      Absolute poverty
      National
      25.1
      28.0
      28.4
      26.9
      36.8
      Rural
      24.3
      28.3
      28.6
      26.3
      36.7
      Urban
      27.3
      26.3
      26.4
      30.7
      37.4
      Source: Economic Review – 2000.

      In the above table it can be stated that in the urban area the poor is larger than rural area due to population pressure, lack of employment opportunity, lack of housing facilities.
      It is mentioned that standard of life of people in the rural area have improved. In another study conducted in the urban area in 1995, it is observed that 60.86% people are poor and within this 40.2% people are absolutely poor. But 90% of the poor people use pure drinking water and 41% use the sanitary latrine, have mentioned in the report. 22% of the income of the rural people and 27% of the income of the poor are spend in crisis coping in the rural area, have also mentioned in the report.

      The changes in rural poverty from 1987 – 1994 can be show in a table as follows:

      Table 03. Types of poverty and its distribution in (%)

      Types
      1987
      1989/90
      1994
      Absolute poor
      25.8
      30.7
      22.5
      Poor
      31.7
      28.6
      29.7
      Poor & absolute poor
      57.5
      59.3
      51.7
      Poverty gap ratio
      21.7
      24.8
      19.2
      Source: Dynamic of rural poverty in Bangladesh, BIDS, April – 1996


      Recent Trend: In a survey of Bangladesh Bureau of Statistics (BBS) it has informed that the rate of poverty fall to 44.7% from 47%. In 1999 the rate of urban poverty was 43.3% and 44.9% in rural area. From this information it can be said a small positive change exists in the poverty situation. The recent trend of poverty can be easily presented by a table, as follows:

      Table 04. Percentile distribution of poverty in Bangladesh.

      Region
      1995/96
      1991/92
      1988/89
      1985/86
      1983/84

      Poverty
      National
      47.5
      47.5
      47.8
      55.7
      62.6
      Rural
      47.1
      47.6
      47.8
      54.7
      61.9
      Urban
      49.7
      46.7
      47.6
      62.6
      67.7

      Absolute poverty
      National
      25.1
      28.0
      28.4
      26.9
      36.8
      Rural
      24.3
      28.3
      28.6
      26.3
      36.7
      Urban
      27.3
      26.3
      26.4
      30.7
      37.4
      Source: Economic Review-2000
      According to the table, it can be stated that the rural poverty is higher than urban poverty. Again both the national poverty and urban poverty are more or less closer to each other due to the existence of large amount of rural areas.


      Bangladesh has achieved quite improvements in social and economic indicators. The annual growth rate of GDP during 1991-1997 was 3.2 per cent. And GDP further expanded at the rate of 5.5 per cent during 1996-1999 despite huge damages brought by recurring floods in 1998/99. Real gross GDP has increased by 64 percent during 1991-2000 as major sectors like agriculture; service and industry have shown significant growth by 41 percent, 58 percent and 103 percent respectively. It should be noted that per capita income growth rate of 3.7 percent per annum during 19996-99 is respectable performance especially with high population growth at 1.8 percent per year. The incidence of poverty has decreased from 58.8 percent in 1991-92 to 49.8 percent in 2000. However, despite its 9 percent decrease, actual numbers of poor remain the same at 63 millions due to a high population growth. The incidence of extreme poverty has also decreased from 42.7 percent to 33.7 percent in 2000 and the number has also decreased from 45.2 million to 42.5 million. The poverty rate is higher at rural areas at 53 percent than at urban areas at 36.6 percent in 2000. There have been remarkable improvements in human poverty indexes. Progress in reducing some aspects of deprivation was faster than in case of others. According to the UNDP report, total fertility rate has dropped from 6.3 in 1975 to 4.3 in 1991, and further gone down to 3.3 in 1997-1999. Accordingly, population growth rate has gone down from 2.9 percent per annum in the mid-1970s to 1.6 percent in the late 1990s. Infant mortality rate has declined from 104.6 per 1,000 live births in 1985-89 to 92.8 in 1990-94 and further to 66.3 in 1995-99. Maternal mortality rate is believed to have declined from 6 per 1,000 live births to 4.4-4.8. Declining mortality rates have led to an increase in average longevity of the population and life expectancy at birth improved from 55/56 years in the 1980s to 60 years in 1999-2000. The overall adult literacy rate increased from about 26 percent in the mid-70s to 29 percent and to 60 percent by 1999. The gross enrollment in primary schools has increased from 59 percent in 1982 to 96 percent in 1999. The gender gap in gross enrollment at the primary has significantly narrowed down in the order of 6 percent in 1999.

      Role of NGOs in Poverty Reduction

      Poverty is one of the important problems in our country. It creates other many problems for the people. In this situation, it is very much necessary to alleviate the poverty from Bangladesh. For poverty alleviation, different organizations, NGOs and associations have taken various effective programmes and steps. On the other hand government also has taken some plans and policies for poverty alleviation. In 2000-20001 fiscal year, government has declared a large amount of money for poverty alleviation and rural development now I would like to mention the following steps, programmes, plan and fiscal also should be followed for poverty alleviation Bangladesh.
      •  At first, to decrease the population growth rate by giving proper training and facilities of health and family planning training center.
      •  To ensure the equal distribution of resources which is available in the country.
      •  To create the employment opportunities for the poor by expanding and establishing cottage and small-scale industries.
      •  To remove the poverty, it is necessary to increase the productivity by using modern technology and skilled manpower.
      • To create skilled manpower by providing proper training for the unskilled manpower.
      •    We can reduce poverty through micro-credit facilities among the poor people.
      •   All cultivable land can be converted into three-cropped land by means of irrigation.
      •   To raise literacy rate by taking various programmes—Food for education programme, Compulsory primary education, adult education etc.
      • Facilitate agriculture development through institutional support and expansion of irrigation.
      • Increase basic physical infrastructure (roads, markets) in the rural area.
      • Promote participation of women in development activities.
      • Utilize the resource properly to reduce poverty.
      • Remove the social corruption for poverty alleviation.
      • Increase the awareness of poor people by teaching and proper training. 
      • Various NGOs can play a vital role for poverty alleviation. So, we should take the opportunities of different projects and programmes of NGOs and association, such as--- Grameen Bank Prokalpa (GBP), Small Farmers credit project (SFCP) etc. 
      • We can alleviate poverty by taking proper plan and utilization of resource

      NGOs:

      Microcredit Programmes

      Over the years, Bangladesh has emerged as the pioneer in innovating and managing microcredit programmes for income/employment generation along with social programmes and support activities. Microcredit programmes have a wide network in the country involving both the Government agencies and the NGO sector. The Bangladesh Rural Development Board (BRDB) disbursed more than Tk. 17 billion as microcredit to 1.3 million beneficiaries during 1991-2000.17 There exist many other institutions which are involved in microcredit including the NGOs. The Palli Karma Sahayak Foundation (PKSF) is a Government financed institution which disbursed nearly Tk. 8 billion through NGOs till December 2000. The Grameen Bank’s cumulative disbursement of microcredit was Tk. 137 billion till December 2000. While comprehensive statistics are difficult to arrive at, available information show that different microfinance NGOs distributed more than Tk. 109 billion to 10 million borrowers till June 2000 (CDF 2001). The microcredit activities, in general, are economically efficient which generate a net surplus for the poor borrowers. These programmes also create positive impact on socioeconomic indicators including children’s schooling, nutrition, and fertility (Khandker 1998). What is impressive about microcredit is its massive expansion in recent years covering nearly half of the target households (usually defined as those having half an acre of land).

      To bring the rural poor into mainstream of development, NGOS focuses on nstitution building as a strategy. NGOS believes that a common platform that is created and owned by the poor is a prerequisite through which the poor can make themselves count in the development process. The Village Organization (VO) is an association of the poor and the landless people who come together with the help of NGOS to try and improve their socioeconomic position. NGOS’s approach to social and economic development of the poor, especially women, involves four inter-related strategies: institution building, service delivery, social mobilization and public sector mobilization.

      NGOS’s core approach and competency is the delivery of health, education, microfinance, and microenterprise services on a large scale to the rural poor, primarily women. NGOS decided to train local women to help deliver these services and organize local groups. As a result, NGOS’s service delivery contributes to building local leadership and local organizations.

      As of December 2002, NGOS had organized its 3.53 million members into 113,756 VOs across the country. NGOS’s microfinance staff meet VOs once a week to discuss and facilitate credit operations, the social development staff meet VO members twice a month to discuss various socioeconomic and legal issues and the health staff meet with the VOs once a month to discuss health issues.



      BRAC is a leading NGO in Bangladesh. The programmes of BRAC are as follows as an NGO Example.


      The microfinance program of BRAC is a tool for poverty alleviation and empowering the poor. Lack of access to the formal banking system deprives them of the facilities to borrow, save and invest in productive activities, and this is a major reason why poor people remain poor. The formal banking sector also requires collateral. Making credit available to the rural poor enables them to become involved in different income generating activities which, in turn, allows them to become economically self-reliant. Through this process BRAC’s microfinance program works to create a self-sustaining and reliable financial service program for the poor.

      Credit

      Credit is provided to its VO members to initiate different income generating activities. While loans for individual and joint activities do not require collateral, members must have some savings with BRAC before they are eligible for loans. Credit operations are carried out through a Revolving Loan Fund (RLF). This RLF consists of donors’ fund, members’ savings, Polli Karmo Shohayok Foundation (PKSF) loan and other loans. Loans realized from VO members are credited to and form part of the RLF for extending further credit. A 2% loan loss reserve is kept to cover the risk of bad debts and death. Regular borrowing and payments allow the borrower to take larger loans.

      Key Features of Loan

      - Loan range: US$ 17 (Tk.1,000) to US$ 345 (Tk. 20,000)
      - Service Charge: 15%
      - Repayment mechanism: Equal weekly installments
      - Loan products: General loan, sector program loan, housing loan and emergency loans given at the time of disaster

      In 2002, US$ 294 million (Tk. 1,707 crore) has been disbursed to 2.9 million borrowers with repayment rate of over 98%.

      Savings

      Savings is an important component of microfinance services. Experiences show that there is a positive correlation between savings and sustainable credit operation. From the member ’s point of view, savings represent an opportunity to save in small amounts to form a lump sum that earns interest. This is an opportunity that the formal market or regular financial institutions do not provide.

      Micro Enterprise Lending and Assistance (MELA)

      Micro Enterprise Lending and Assistance (MELA) program was launched in December 1996 to provide loan to small enterprises with growth potential. The objective of this program is to provide credit facilities and technical assistance to new and existing small businesses.

      The characteristics of MELA loans are:

      - Loan range: US$ 345 (Tk. 20,000) - US$ 3,448 (Tk. 200,000)
      - Service Charge: 15%
      - Repayment modality: Equal monthly installments
      - Loan duration: 12 months, 18 months and 24 months
      - Twenty different business sectors are supported by MELA loan

      By the end of 2002, a total amount of US$ 48 million (Tk. 260 crore) was disbursed to 45,503 borrowers in 64 districts of Bangladesh with an average loan size of US$ 1,077 (Tk. 62,484).



      BRAC has learned that besides lack of access to finance, the two major constraints that have prevented the poor from improving their lives are the absence of self-employment opportunities and lack of skills to sustain those activities. BRAC realised that if different employment opportunities were created, along with sufficient training and refreshers for capacity development, the poor could be linked to the mainstream economy which would ultimately bring them out of poverty.

      Activities approved for BRAC sectoral lending and other support enterprises can be classified under the following broad categories.

      Poultry & Livestock Program
      Approximately 70% of the rural landless women are directly or indirectly involved in traditional poultry rearing activities. The Poultry and Livestock Program is composed of several components: poultry and livestock extension program, poultry farms and hatcheries, feed mills and feed analysis laboratories, bull station and the disease diagnosis laboratories.

      Till to date, 1.96 million people have been involved in this program.

      The key persons under poultry and livestock extension program are i) Poultry and Livestock Extension Worker ii) Chick Rearer iii) Key Rearer iv) Cage Rearer v) Broiler Rearer vi) Egg Collector vii) Model Cow Rearer viii) Model Goat Rearer and ix) Artificial Inseminator.

      Fisheries
      The Fisheries Program, started in 1976, is now developed into one of the most promising and profitable EIG activities for rural women. The key components of the program are pond aquaculture, open water fisheries management, and fish and prawn hatchery.

      BRAC aims to promote pond aquaculture by rural women to provide them with an additional source of income and improve their nutrition level thereby improving socioeconomic condition of the participants. BRAC provides training, undertakes production and distribution of quality fish spawn and prawn post larvae, extends credit assistance, and technical and marketing support. Till to date 47,421 acres of water-body have been brought under fish culture and 234,412 farmers are involved in fisheries program.

      Social Forestry
      The social forestry program is being implemented since 1988 to make the people aware of the necessity of planting trees and to increase the number and variety of trees not only to meet the basic needs such as timber, fuel and fruit but also to restore the ecological balance. The program components are horticulture nursery, grafting nursery and agro-forestry. One of the objectives of the program is to encourage people to plant trees throughout the country.

      At present there are 73,508 agro and social forestry farmers.

      Agriculture
      The agricultural extension activities can be broadly categorized into vegetable cultivation and crop diversification (rice, maize, wheat, cotton, sunflower). This program has been undertaken to increase the nutrition and income levels of the households by increasing agricultural production of VO members through technology transfer. Under this program VO members, who have less than 0.5 acres of land in each area, receive training, technical support, inputs like HYV and hybrid seeds, fertilizers, and have access to BRAC’s microfinance to obtain the resources for investing in farming. Interested small farmers, who have land between 0.5 and 3 acres, also receive training and technical support.

      Crop diversification contributes to increased agricultural productivity. Besides maize and wheat, which are used for poultry feed, rice, cotton, onion, mustard and sunflower cultivation are also being undertaken.

      By December 2002, there were 157,280 vegetable growers brining 67,114 acres of land under vegetable cultivation and 1,169.37 MT of seeds have been distributed.

      Sericulture
      Sericulture is a labor intensive agro-industry. Sericulture Program links the rural producers with urban markets. The main components of the program are:

      a) mulberry cultivation (roadside, homestead and bush),
      b) silkworm rearing,
      c) reeling and weaving, and
      d) marketing.

      Besides, there are other components of the sericulture program, which include silk Seed Production Centre and Sericulture Resource Centre (SRC). At present, BRAC is operating 8 Silk Seed Production Centres, 6 Sericulture Resource Centres, and 3 Reeling Centres.

      The Sericulture Resource Centre provides practical training to the rearers on mulberry cultivation and silkworm rearing. In 2002, there were 7,407 silkworm rearers and 1.4 million Disease Free Laying (DFL) have been distributed.


      Poor farmers require better skills and knowledge of modern agriculture practices. They also need assistance to obtain a fair price for their produce. BRAC Vegetable Export Program seeks to link the poor Bangladeshi farmers with international markets to bridge the gap between the local producers and the international consumers, in addition to introduction of technical training and modern agricultural inputs. BRAC started this program in 1997-98 with particular focus on vegetables that have high demand in the European markets and could be grown in Bangladesh. In the first year, 27 tons of beans were exported successfully to England, France, Belgium and Holland and in 1999, 26 tons of fresh potatoes were exported to Singapore.

      BRAC has exported 621 tons of fresh vegetables and 350 tons of potatoes in 2002 to the wholesalers and supermarkets in England, France, Germany, the Netherlands, Belgium and Italy in Europe, and the UAE, Bahrain, Singapore, Malaysia and Hong Kong in Asia. In addition to French beans, Broccoli and Green chilli, demand oriented new items have been selected with the total export target of 800 tons of fresh vegetables and 1000 tons of potatoes for the year 2003.


      Rural Enterprise Project (REP)
      As the scope of employment and income earning sectors are limited, new livelihood opportunities are essential for reducing rural poverty. Moreover, many traditional livelihoods are becoming marginal and new opportunities are opening up with growing urbanization and globalization. However, the poor may not be able to gain from these opportunities without support. This realization led BRAC to initiate the Rural Enterprise Project (REP), to encourage employment and income generation through entrepreneurship. The project is involved in innovating non-traditional activities and introducing them to the program participants. REP was formed in 1985 to find and test new opportunities for rural development. The primary objective was to experiment with various income generating enterprises that can be owned and managed by rural landless women.

      One significant change that took place in REP was the inclusion of a new unit called Non-farm Enterprises Extension and Reinforcement (NEER) to intensify the non-farm job creation program. The objective is to create employment in the non-farm sector for rural women and BRAC School graduates to make them self-employed. The present women owned and run projects under NEER program are:

      Till 2002, a total of 9,410 restaurants, 30,675 grocery stores, 5,468 laundries, 13,418 tailoring shops and 3,637 other micro enterprises were operated by women members throughout the country.



      Role of Government Organizations in Poverty Reduction

      Poverty is one of the important problems in our country. It creates other many problems for the people. In this situation, it is very much necessary to alleviate the poverty from Bangladesh. For poverty alleviation, different organizations, NGOs and associations have taken various effective programmes and steps. On the other hand government also has taken some plans and policies for poverty alleviation. In 2000-20001 fiscal year, government has declared a large amount of money for poverty alleviation and rural development now I would like to mention the following steps, programmes, plan and fiscal also should be followed for poverty alleviation Bangladesh.

      • At first, to decrease the population growth rate by giving proper training and facilities of health and family planning training center.
      • To ensure the equal distribution of resources which is available in the country.
      • To create the employment opportunities for the poor by expanding and establishing cottage and small-scale industries.
      • To remove the poverty, it is necessary to increase the productivity by using modern technology and skilled manpower.
      • To create skilled manpower by providing proper training for the unskilled manpower.
      • We can reduce poverty through micro-credit facilities among the poor people.
      • All cultivable land can be converted into three-cropped land by means of irrigation.
      • To raise literacy rate by taking various programmes—Food for education programme, Compulsory primary education, adult education etc.
      • Facilitate agriculture development through institutional support and expansion of irrigation.
      • Increase basic physical infrastructure (roads, markets) in the rural area.
      • Promote participation of women in development activities.
      • Utilize the resource properly to reduce poverty.
      • Remove the social corruption for poverty alleviation.
      • Increase the awareness of poor people by teaching and proper training.
      • Various NGOs can play a vital role for poverty alleviation. So, we should take the opportunities of different projects and programmes of NGOs and association, such as--- Grameen Bank Prokalpa (GBP), Small Farmers credit project (SFCP) etc.
      • We can alleviate poverty by taking proper plan and utilization of resource.

      Government Organizations:
      The Economic Development Program (EDP) works with and for the disadvantaged rural people of Bangladesh, especially women, and it has a compelling vision of a society where the poor and disadvantaged will be able to achieve sustainable improvement in their livelihoods, attain a high degree of self reliance and manage their own affairs with dignity and freedom.

      In the last three decades, with more than three and a half million rural women, it has been able to reach a large number of poor people. EDP has been working in all the 64 districts of Bangladesh and has a wide range of interventions including institution building, microfinance, sector program, social development and health intervention. EDP's greatest strength lies in its innovative development programs and learning from experiences.

      Bangladesh has made great strides since its independence in 1971--in foodgrain production, prevention of famines, effective response to natural calamities, and achievements on the social front. Rural poverty, however, remains extensive. More than half of Bangladeshis are below the poverty line and about 90 percent of the poor live in rural areas.

      "To reduce poverty, it is crucial to develop rural areas--where most of the poor people live. This study identifies ways of accelerating growth in rural areas. Poverty in Bangladesh must tbe reduced by helping agriculture and rural non-farm sectors grow faster and by strengthening rural institutions that empower rural people to improve their income and welfare.

      "The study identifies the critical constraints that prevent Bangladesh from realizing its strong potential to increase agricultural and rural non-farm growth. It also draws lessons from different programs to develop rural institutions and reduce poverty in order to design the future strategy.

      "The proposed rural development strategy addresses the critical constraints to rural growth and to the building of rural institutions within a medium-term time frame. The key propositions of the strategy are to: i) improve short-term food assistance and reform food policy, ii) reform policy environment and public sector programs for farm and non-farm growth, iii) invest in improved infrastructure, iv) improve the efficiency of the rural financial system, and v) build a strong local government system."

      In Bangladesh, the approach to poverty alleviation, particularly reduction of income poverty, covers several channels. An important channel is economic growth. Although the impact of economic growth on poverty is somewhat indirect, high economic growth, along

      with measures to influence the ‘quality’ of growth such that its poverty alleviating capacity is increased, is an important element of a successful anti-poverty strategy in the country. In addition, direct efforts to reduce poverty cover several routes e.g. capability–raising of the poor by education, health and nutrition interventions; targeted employment, and safety nets programmes; and improvements in non-material dimensions of well-being including gender gaps, insecurity, powerlessness and social exclusion. In short, the approach sets three broad imperatives in the fight against poverty:

      First, opportunities for employment and productivity growth must be created so that incomes rise and the poor are able to move out of poverty; Second, measures must be put in place to ensure that access to basic services is equitable so that the poor can benefit; and

      Third, special measures must be taken to reduce the vulnerability of the poor to unforeseen events and shocks.

      Over the years, significant diversity has emerged among each of these broad channels. The growth enhancing interventions, along with economic sectors and infrastructure development, have covered elements of good governance and an enabling environment such that growth prospects are enhanced. Similarly, the direct approach to reducing poverty has been broadened to cover different programmes. Along with microcredit based employment programmes which rely more on self-employment generation, other types of income transfer programmes have been evolved. At present, the Government’s targeted programmes cover a broad range of activities: food aid to create safety-nets for the poor, building and maintenance of rural infrastructure, rural development programmes, primary and girls education programmes, microcredit and other specific welfare programmes. While the initial focus of most of these programmes was on ‘transfer elements’ to supplement consumption, create employment opportunities, and help the poor to acquire access to income generating assets, significant changes have taken place in their approach and design to strengthen the development impact of the programmes. While such diversity in targeted anti-poverty instruments serves the immediate needs of different poverty groups, this also raises a moot policy issue: What should be the relative priority of different instruments for ensuring accelerated poverty reduction? In view of significant complementarities among these programmes as well as observed differentials across different poverty groups, one probably may not suggest an ‘either-or’ approach. But certainly it is desirable to identify relative impact of different approaches on the poverty reduction process and generate priorities in specific contexts, given the resource constraints. In short, this will help the policy makers to move towards a more ‘optimal mix’ of targeted anti-poverty programmes.


      Food Assisted Programmes
      Bangladesh has one of the largest systems of targeted food transfer programmes in the world through which, since 1993/94, more than 1 million metric tons of foodgrains are channelled to the target population. The food assisted programmes generally act as conduits of transfer to enhance household food security and, in many cases, as a means of promoting human development of the poor. During the 1990s, resources channelled through these programmes increased significantly (Table 3.1). The share of foodgrains distributed through food assisted programmes in the Public Food Distribution System (PFDS) also rose sharply in the 1990s: from less than 30 per cent in the early 1980s to over 80 per cent in the late 1990s.14

      Table: Profile of food assisted programmes


      Source: Food Assisted Programme Documents.


      Rural Infrastructure Development Programmes:
      The rural infrastructure development programmes support building and maintenance of rural roads, bridges and culverts, small scale irrigation structures, development of trading facilities in rural markets, and creation of trading network. The Local Government Engineering Department (LGED), under the Ministry of Local Government, Rural Development and Cooperatives, is involved in the development of rural infrastructure including rural roads, growth centres, embankments and other physical facilities.


      Another unique programme of ‘cash for work’ in rural infrastructure development is the Rural Maintenance Programme (RMP) which started in 1983. All the beneficiaries of RMP are women. The programme employs 41,000 destitute rural women (with land ownership of less than 0.5 acre) from 4,100 unions of 435 upazilas in 61 districts as RMP crews. They are employed on a daily wage basis for maintenance of 15 miles of rural earthen road throughout the year. The RMP crews maintain a total of 42,596 km of rural roads in the country and remain in the payroll for a period of four years after which they graduate from the programme. The crews are organized and provided with training on income generating activities during involvement with RMP to assist them in livelihood activities using their own savings.


      The Rural Maintenance Programme (RMP):
      This program is similar to FFW programmes and is implemented by Union Parishads with assistance of CARE-Bangladesh. With the dual objective of maintaining rural earthen roads and providing employment and training to destitute women, RMP covers about 4,100 union parishads in the country. In each union, 20 km of rural roads, built under IFFD-FFW programme, are maintained by a road maintenance association (RMA) comprising 10 destitute women. The RMA is responsible for maintaining the given stretch of road with quality monitoring done by a union parishad member. The union parishad and a Project Implementation Committee oversee the beneficiary selection process. The eligibility criteria include: being divorced, separated, or otherwise destitute; work. The participating women are enrolled in a four-year programme of RMP work and training during which they are paid Tk. 43 per day as wages (about one-fourth per cent is retained as savings on their behalf). During the last year of the project cycle, the women are given more intensive training in basic business management to help them in pursuing gainful activities after graduation from the project.